Silver,
I am not sure what is more \"off\" with this post, your reading of the PP\'s or your assumptions about trainer intent with the top 2 Derby Candidates.
Eskenderaya is not \"gunning and wiring\" any field. Pletcher may not have won a Derby, but he certainly knows the best formula for winning one. Eskenereaya will leave the gate and tuck/stalk, just like he did in the Fountain of Youth, most likely sitting just off of the rail horse, Most Happy Fella. He will inherit the lead on the far turn and then have to hold off the horses you named, Schoolyard Dreams and Awesome Act. Whether the race is \"bettable\" or not, depends on how short Eskenderaya goes off. if he goes off 3-5 or lower, I believe the race is bettable. There was nothing wrong with is Tampa Bay Derby, but any time a good trainer changes his game plan with a horse to give them more time off after a big effort, that is enough of a reason for me to think \"bounce\" is on the way and take a shot against. I thought the finish of the Tampa Bay derby showed 3 horses that had nothing left. However, with the premature move by Rose and now the switch to Dominguez, I can take a shot with Schoolyard Dreams in this race if I can get 9-2 or so.
As for the Santa Anita Derby, not sure why you would think Lucky is getting a \"free pass\". Have you looked at the races by Sydney\'s Candy at all? yes, he caught a relatively soft pace last time but he was sprinting in the stretch. I see him likely getting ANOTHER relatively soft pace tomorrow. He should strech out OK IMO as he is by Candy Ride, who beat Medaglia at 1 1/4 in the Pacific Classic. Assuming that #3 Who\'s Up doesn\'t go \"gung ho\" for the lead or the ever unpredictable Pro-Ride isn\'t killing speed, Sydney\'s Candy should be tough to beat in the Santa Anita Derby. Not to mention that there is no way that Baffert will have the screws tightened on Lookin at Lucky for this one. The \"mediocre synthetic final prep\" strategy has worked fine the last few years for the Derby. (see Street Sense).
IMO now is a good time to bet against both Eskenderaya and Lookin at Lucky.
Good luck to all.
Jim