All the winners sans Baffert in the last 10 years have not been heard from again. If there is not a stand out in the race, the trip a horse receives becomes much of a factor than pace.
Ever since they went away from earnings to points to determine the derby field, the sprinter / miler types have not gotten into the race.
I don\'t think they even give points to any race under a mile anymore. I preferred the earnings to get into the derby, but understand why CDI changed it. They can control the points a race is awarded, but not the purse.
So when a race like the Delta Downs Jackpot for 2 year olds, has a million dollar purse, and the winner pretty much secures a spot in the derby, CDI does not like it, so points it is.
The earnings system brought together the best 3 year olds of the crop. Now they bring in set of horses that have competed in chosen races.
Who would you rather see in the race, horses who have won some nice races up to a mile , or a horse like Madaket Road who has basically gotten into the derby by getting minor placing in prep races. Even though it seems he is going in the Pat Day Mile.
What about making the points only for first and second place, in any stakes race run, giving the most points to Grade 1 races and the least amount to listed stakes races?