Again-- the main reason McCain was always the favorite to win was by default.
A guy who used to work here had an expression: Larry Bird good looking. From a distance Bird looked okay, but the closer you got...
None of the Republican nominees other than McCain could stand up to any kind of scrutiny from the usual Republican voters. Romney not only has the Mormon thing, he has flip flopped on BIG Republican issues. Huckabee has a lot going for him (and is the likely Vice Presidential candidate), but his resume is lacking, especially in foreign policy. And Guliani-- aside from the isues already raised here, and Kerik, and the NY firefighters and cops and 9/11 widows following him around to explain that he was no hero at all on 9/11, and his anti-party positions on abortion and gays, three marriages, and keeping secret his client list since he left office, and not attending the meetings of the 9/11 Commission and getting asked to leave (or quitting, depending on who you believe)...
The one guy who actually could derail McCain in the unlikely event he ever gets any traction is Thompson. He\'s completely by-the-book in his positions, acts and looks the part, and if he ever gets going the big money from the party establishment will come pouring in. I took a little of him at 22-1 as a saver.
There\'s a pretty good story on Guliani in the 1/7 New Yorker for anyone who wants an overview.