I know this is highly subjective, but IMO Curlin had excuses in all his losses. Perhaps they weren\'t big enough to account for the loss, but they were excuses.
1. He had a tough trip in the Derby.
2. The Belmont was a slow paced race. We\'ve seen repeatedly that the winner of slow paced races is not always the best horse. It\'s the horse that gets the jump or that can finish with the greatest brilliance while fresh. I am a huge fan of Rags to Riches, but I believe had the pace been faster and really tapped what each of those horses had inside instead of it being a sprint home from the top of the stretch, Curlin would have gotten the best of her.
3. He was wide in the Haskell on a day when inside speed and inside stalkers seemed to have an advantage (Any Given Saturday sat in the pocket with a perfect trip and disappointed next out. Curlin came back with a huge effort. Both support the case).
I\'m not sure where to rank this horse yet, but IMO he\'s one of the better ones we\'ve seen recently. I would have liked to have seen Curlin vs. Invasor.