Silver, I tried to find the results online and failed. However, Skip Away only won the one HOY, in 1998, not two. He probably should have won in \'97, but he didn\'t win that many races in an aggressive campaign, and Favorite Trick won HOY that year as a 2YO. By the time \'98 wrapped up it had become pretty clear that Skip Away had been jobbed the previous year, so, perhaps this time he did get the benefit of the \"makeup\" call. But he did have a hell of a year in \'98, winning graded races all over the place from Winter in Florida (Donn, Gulfstream Park H\'Cap), to Spring in Maryland (Pimlico Special) and California (Hollywood Gold Cup), to late Summer in New York (Woodward). Awards are funny things. Sometimes, it seems like they are awarded to the right individuals, but at the wrong time. See Scorsese, Martin.