Just want to add a vote for Sperry\'s, went last year for wife\'s birthday. We have a house load of kids and don\'t get out as often as we like, so it\'s important to us that when we do get out, we have a good time. Got great food and phenomenal service (par for the course there) last year. Everyone has different opinions on what makes for a great meal out but for us, service has a lot to do with it, and Sperry\'s does it right.
Also agree on Mama Mia\'s. Fair warning, this is a classic red sauce place, some folks think red sauce places are old/boring/dated, etc., but the Papa Chach famiglia ain\'t those kinda folks, and sometimes you need a good classic chicken parm without the bother of making it at home.
If you want to take a 1/2 hour drive down to the state capital, highly recommend New World.
If you\'re looking for a place to get sammiches to bring out to the track with you ignore the Putnam Market hype and drive the few extra blocks to Roma.
Overrated in my humble opinion: Hattie\'s (despite the lofty reputation their dried, er, fried chicken chicken wasn\'t in the same universe as my Nana\'s), Brook Tavern (my wife got a shrimp dish there that may have been the single saltiest thing either of us have ever eaten at a restaurant) Forno (slowest service east of the Mississippi during my lone visit there). Cantina is an absolute must-to-avoid, cannot believe that place is still open, what with middling-at-best food and utterly putrid service.